A cluttered table stacked with pizza boxes from every imaginable restaurant and store

Definitive Grove City Pizza Guide

After months of research, blind taste tests, community surveys, heated Nextdoor arguments, and one regrettable Thursday where we ate pizza for all three meals, our editorial team is proud to publish what experts are calling the most thorough pizza analysis in Grove City history. Here’s a list of the top 29 pizza places in Grove City in no particular order: Kroger Flyers Tammy's Pizza Cottage Dollar General Fazoli's Massey's Donatos Romeo's Pizza Hut Papa Johns Joseppi's Marco's Jet's Zanzis Little Caesars Domino's Grandstand Plank's Cattleman's Santino's Westside Slice Emelio's Formaggio Sbarro Roosters Josie's Meijer Giant Eagle Speedway Notably absent from this year’s rankings is Zamarelli’s. Much like Windows Phone, it doesn’t exist anymore, but some people still can’t get over it. ...

February 3, 2026 · 1 min · 121 words · Editor-in-chief, Grove City Growler